The position of Metropolitan Hierotheos (Vlachos) as a component of the “Theory of thePrimacy of Power” of the Patriarchate of Constantinople
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51216/2687-072X_2025_1_143-166Keywords:
unity of the Church, institution of primacy, Patriarchate of Constantinople , Russian Orthodox Church, Ukrainian issue, anti-Russian rhetoric, autocephaly.Abstract
The article examines the views of one of the outstanding Greek theologians, Metropolitan Hierotheos (Vlachos), as part of the “Theory of Primacy of Power” of the Patriarch of Constantinople in connection with the so-called Ukrainian question. After the Russian Orthodox Church broke off Eucharistic communion with the Patriarchate of Constantinople in October 2018, Metropolitan Hierotheos outlined his theory on granting autocephaly from the position of the Church of Constantinople. This theory, in essence, is a distortion of Orthodox ecclesiology, since the institution of primacy violates equal relations between Local Orthodox Churches.
At the beginning of the article, Metropolitan Hierotheos’s theory of an autocephalous Church is examined. His confidence in the special right of Constantinople to grant autocephaly is unfounded, since one Local Church is granted an excessive privilege that goes beyond its honorary rights and obligations. The Metropolitan’s theory of the gradual granting of autocephaly is examined in detail: 1) “by oikonomia” by the Patriarch of Constantinople, and then 2) “by akrivia”, by the All-Church Council. In any case, the Metropolitan supports the Patriarch of Constantinople in his actions leading to a schism, which complicates the possibility of restoring peace between the Local Orthodox Churches.
In conclusion, the author summarizes: the anti-Russian rhetoric of Metropolitan Hierotheus testifies to his biased and unscientific approach to the history of Russia and the Russian Church. His distorted understanding of history allows him to “justify” the decisions of Constantinople, which radically violated peace and harmony in the Ecumenical Church.
For citation: Dionisius (Shlenov A. V.), hegumen The position of Metropolitan Hierotheos (Vlachos) as a component of the “Theory of the Primacy of Power” of the Patriarchate of Constantinople DOI: 10.51216/2687‑072Х_2025_1_143-166. EDN: BKMSKF // Theological Collection of Tambov Theological Seminary. 2025, no. 1 (30). P. 143–166. (In Russian).Downloads
References
1. Дионисий (Шлёнов), игум. Кто является главой Церкви? К вопросу о теории первенства // Богословский вестник : научно‑богословский журнал Московской духовной академии. 2023. № 1 (48). С. 127–168.
2. Иерофей (Влахос), митр. Одна ночь в пустыне Святой Горы : беседа с пустынником об Иисусовой молитве. Сергиев Посад : Издательство Свято‑Троицкой Сергиевой Лавры, 2017. 187 с.
3. Иерофей (Влахос), митр. Православная психотерапия: свято‑отеческий курс врачевания души. Сергиев Посад : Издательство Свято‑Троицкой Сергиевой Лавры, 2005. 368 с. 4. Солнцев Ф. Г. Древности Российского Государства. Т. 1. Святые иконы, кресты, утварь храмовая и облачение сана духовного // Геральдическая библиотека : сайт. URL: https://lib.geraldika.ru/t/3204 (дата обращения: 04.02.2024).
5. Βαβούσκος Α. Κ. Το ουκρανικό ζήτημα. Θεσσαλονίκη : Μέθεξις, 2020.
6. Ἱερόθεος Βλάχος, Μητροπολίτης Ναυπάκτου καί Ἁγίου Βλασίου. Τό συνοδικό καί ἱεραρχικό πολίτευμα τῆς Ἐκκλησίας μέ ἀναφορά στό Οὐκρανικό ζήτημα. Ἱερά Μονή Γενεθλίου τῆς Θεοτόκου (Πελαγίας), 2019.
7. Λάλλος Ἀ.-Ἰ. Ἱστορία τῆς Ἐκκλησίας τῆς Ρωσίας, ἡ θεωρία τῆς Τρίτης Ρώμης. Διπλωματική εργασία. Θεσσαλονίκη, 2016.
8. Τρωϊανος ́ Σ. Ν., Πουλης́ Γ. Α. Εκκλησιαστικό Δίκαιο. Αθήνα : Αντ. Ν. Σακκούλας, 2003.
REFERENCES
1. Hierotheus (Vlachos), Metropolitan Bogoslovie i pastyrstvo. Beseda so studentami Moskovskoi dukhovnoi seminarii [Theology and pastoral care. A talk with students of the Moscow Theological Academy]. Sait Pravoslavie.ru [Pravoslavie.ru Website]. Part 1, (20.09.2009a). (In Russian). Available at: http://pravoslavie.ru/38020.html (accessed: 25.11.2024).
2. Hierotheus (Vlachos), Metropolitan Bogoslovie i pastyrstvo. Beseda so studentami Moskovskoi dukhovnoi seminarii [Theology and pastoral care. A talk with students of the Moscow Theological Academy]. Ofitsial’nyi sait Moskovskogo Patriarkha Pravoslavie.ru [Pravoslavie.ru Official Website of the Moscow Patriarchate]. Part 2, (20.09.2009b). (In Russian). Available at: http://pravoslavie.ru/38139.html (accessed: 25.11.2024).
3. Hierotheos (Vlachos), Metropolitan Bogoslovie kak nauka i kak dar [Theology as a science and as a gift]. Sait Bogoslov.ru [Bogoslov.ru Website]. (In Russian). Available at: https://bogoslov.ru/article/470008 (accessed: 06.10.2024).
4. Hierotheos (Vlachos), Metropolitan Moya vstrecha so startsem Paisiem Svyatogortsem (14 November 2012) [My meeting with elder Paisios the Holy Mountain (November 14, 2012)]. (In Russian). Available at: http://pravoslavie.ru/57427.html (accessed: 25.11.2024).
5. Metropolit Navpaktskii Ierofei rasskazal o problemakh s prinyatiem dokumentov na Krite (1 iyulya 2016 g.) [Metropolitan Hierotheos of Nafpaktos spoke about the problems with the adoption of documents in Crete (July 1, 2016)]. Pravoslavnyi zhurnal “Blagodatnyi ogon’” [Orthodox Magazine Holy Fire]. (In Russian). Available at://blagogon.ru/news/448/ (accessed: 25.11.2024).
6. Pozitsiya Moskovskogo Patriarkha po voprosu o pervenstve vo Vselenskoi Tserkvi (26 dekabrya 2013 g.) [The position of the Moscow Patriarchate on the issue of primacy in the Ecumenical Church (December 26, 2013)]. Ofitsial’nyi sait Moskovskogo Patriarkha Patriarkhiya.ru [Official Website of the Moscow Patriarchate Patriarchia.ru]. (In Russian). Available at: http://www.patriarchia.ru/db/text/3481089.html (accessed: 09.08.2023).
7. Studenty Moskovskoi dukhovnoi akadmii vstretilis’ s izvestnym grecheskim bogoslovom mitropolitom Navpaktskim Ierofeem (Vlakhosom) (22 sentyabrya 2009 g.) [Students of the Moscow Theological Academy met with the famous Greek theologian Metropolitan Hierotheos (Vlachos) of Nafpaktos (September 22, 2009)]. Ofitsial’nyi sait Moskovskogo Patriarkha Patriarkhiya.ru [Official Website of the Moscow Patriarchate Patriarchia.ru]. (In Russian). Available at: http://www.patriarchia.ru/db/text/747109.html (accessed: 25.11.2024).
8. Shemlyuk K. Miks UPTs s PTsU v obshchem Sinode: reshenie “ukrainskoi problemy” po‑grecheski (11 sentyabrya 2019 g.) [Mix of the UOC with the OCU in the General Synod: solving the “Ukrainian problem” in Greek (September 11, 2019)]. Soyuz pravoslavnykh zhurnalistov [Union of Orthodox Journalists]. (In Russian). Available at: https://spzh.eu/ru/zashhita‑very/64915‑miks‑upc‑s‑pcu‑v‑obshhem‑sinode‑reshenije‑ukrainskoj‑problemy‑po‑grecheski (accessed: 25.11.2024).
Downloads
Published
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Theological Collection of Tambov Theological Seminary
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
